Newsletters ✍️Writing

How to Write Like a Copywriter (& When to Break the Rules)

written by

Kevin J. Duncan

published on

written by

Kevin J. Duncan

published on

published

written by

Kevin J. Duncan

published


Most of the writers we admire are masters in the art of copywriting.

True, some were chasing conversions. But most learned classical techniques for one reason: they knew how to hold a reader’s attention.

Didn’t matter if you were selling something or just trying to move people. Copywriting let you take a loose idea and shape it into something that made people lean in.

Writers like David Ogilvy, Eugene Schwartz, and Frank Kern turned it into an art form.

And for a long time, if you wanted to get really freakin’ good at writing, those were your teachers. You studied what they did. You tried to write like them. Because if you could, you could write just about anything.

It wasn’t easy. That was the point.

People who pulled it off stood out.

Then AI showed up.

It was trained on all of it: Ogilvy, Schwartz, Kern, the works.

So now anyone can produce something that sounds like polished copy. Same tone. Same rhythm. Same bag of tricks… even if they’ve never read a word of Ogilvy in their life.

Five years ago, this kind of writing would’ve impressed people.

Now it just blends in.

These days, if your sentences use literary devices, clean structure, and a perfect beat… it doesn’t make you sound like a pro.

It makes you sound like you got ChatGPT to do your work for you.

That’s the challenge now.

How do you use the copywriting moves that still work without sounding like everyone else who’s using them?

How do you stay persuasive… without losing your voice in the process?

Why Copywriting Still Works (Even If It’s Been Cloned)

It’s easy to roll your eyes at copywriting now.

We’ve all seen the déjà vu headlines. The social posts that sound like fifty other social posts you’ve read that day. The “attention-grabbing hooks” that all sound like they came out of a swipe file from 2014.

But here’s the thing… the reason it all feels overused is because most of it still works.

People still skim.

People still hesitate.

People still forget what they just read.

And copywriting was built for that.

It knows how to get to the point without losing the thread. It knows how to raise the stakes without sounding like a cartoon villain. And it knows how to guide someone, line by line, all the way to the end.

Copywriting gave us structure. Pacing. Flow.

It showed us how to write in a way that keeps people moving. Not just nodding along, but actually reading.

Even if the tone’s changed… the job hasn’t.

Whether you’re writing a blog post, a sales page, a tweet, or a newsletter, you’re still trying to hold someone’s attention. Still trying to move them from start to finish without losing them halfway.

So yeah. AI learned the formulas.

But the original reason for learning them still stands.

You just have to use them differently (and sparingly) now.

Four Copywriting Moves That Still Work (if You Don’t Use Them Like a Robot)

You don’t need to be a copywriter to use copywriting.

Most writers already are, even if they don’t call it that. They try to open with tension. They guide the reader from one idea to the next without letting go.

That’s copy.

But when those same moves show up too clean, too confident, the whole thing starts to feel synthetic.

You can still use them. You probably should.

You just have to stop making them the star of the show (because people relying on AI use them nonstop).

Here are four copywriting moves that still work… if you use them the right way.

1. The Lead

Copywriters open fast. No intro fluff. No slow buildup.

They start with friction… something off, something honest, something sharp enough to make you pause. It’s not about being clever. A real starting point matters more.

AI does this too now, which is why most hooks sound weirdly confident but hollow.

If your first line feels like it belongs on the cover of a business ebook, it’s probably wrong.

Instead, try anchoring to a specific moment or a quiet realization. Or maybe a line that makes you slightly uncomfortable.

“I almost didn’t publish this.”
“The advice made sense. The outcome didn’t.”
“Twelve drafts in and it still felt off.”

It can whisper… as long as it lands.

2. The Turn

This is where things shift.

Classic copy builds tension, then pivots. Sometimes with a solution, sometimes just a crack of clarity.

AI gets the form right but rushes it. The writing turns too quickly. The discomfort gets resolved before it ever settles in.

The pacing’s off.

And if there’s no real pause before the pivot, the moment won’t land.

So, let the problem sit for a second. Don’t chase the fix. Let the mess be the point.

3. The Proof Layer

Good copy isn’t built on emotion alone. There’s always something underneath (a fact, a moment, a stat, a scene) that keeps it from floating away.

Sometimes that’s data. Other times, it’s a result or a detail specific enough to feel lived-in.

This is where AI fakes it. It leans on clichés… imaginary numbers, vague claims, borrowed authority.

“Trusted by thousands.”
“Experts agree.”
“Game-changing results.”

Skip all of that. Proof doesn’t need volume.

“Opened at 7:42. Bought at 7:47.”
“Four people replied. All of them said the same thing.”
“I changed the headline. The bounce rate dropped by half.”

If it feels real, that’s enough.

4. The Bridge

This one’s invisible when it’s working…

Every sentence is connected to the one before it.

AI struggles here. It knows the tone but not the thread. So it jumps between ideas. Or stacks them without context. Or kills the momentum with a sentence that doesn’t belong.

If something reads fine on its own but breaks the flow, cut it or rewrite it.

Think less about what you’re saying and more about how you’re walking someone through it.

When to Break the Rules

Copywriting gave us structure. It still does.

But if you follow every rule too closely, your writing feels like you’re showing someone what good copy should look like, not actually saying anything that matters.

That’s when it’s time to pull the brakes.

If your rhythm feels rehearsed, or the transition’s too clean, or you’re writing something you wouldn’t say in a real conversation… that’s your signal.

Break it. Mangle the structure. Pause longer than you’re supposed to. Leave something unsaid.

Let one idea trail off without tying it in a bow.

The best writers aren’t following copywriting rules like a checklist; instead, they’re bending them until the structure disappears.

What’s left is voice. And feel. And clarity.

All the stuff that’s hard to fake.

Have a Copy Mind, a Human Voice

It’s fine to think like a copywriter.

It helps with structure and flow.

But the second it starts sounding like you’re trying to “write good copy,” you’re in trouble.

Here’s how to stay grounded.

Draft with some shape, but don’t cling to it

If the piece feels messy, sure, reach for structure. Use the copy moves you know. They’ll help you find a way in.

But don’t force it. If you’re following a framework just to follow it, your readers will be able to tell.

Read the thing like a person

Out loud, in your head, doesn’t matter. If a line makes you cringe or roll your eyes or zone out, that’s a problem.

Most of the time, you’ll catch the off-notes just by listening.

Break the rhythm before it breaks you

When your sentences all start to hit the same beat, you’re not writing as much as you’re performing. AI does this. So do a lot of marketers.

Shift the tempo. Rearrange a thought. Let one thing land too hard and the next one barely land at all.

Don’t chase “better”

It’s easy to think the next draft should be cleaner, tighter, more “professional.”

Forget that.

Figure out where the energy drops or goes flat. Where the thing stops sounding like something you’d actually say.

Fix that stuff and leave the rest alone.

The Bottom Line

Copywriting made a lot of us better writers.

It taught us how to guide attention, how to build momentum, and how to make people care.

But now that AI uses those same moves, sounding genuine is more important than sounding sharp and polished.

So use copywriting techniques when it makes sense to do so.

But use them in moderation.

Because as crazy as it sounds, if your writing is “too good” and “too polished,” readers are less likely to trust it.

They’ll just assume it’s just another piece of lightweight fluff written by AI.

by Kevin J. Duncan
I'm the Head of Content at Kindlepreneur and the former Editor-in-Chief at Smart Blogger. My work focuses on writing, content strategy, and self-publishing, helping authors and creators improve their craft.